Skip to main content

New top story from Time: ‘I Want This Over.’ For Victims and the Accused, Justice Is Delayed as COVID-19 Snarls Courts

https://ift.tt/3aHjIfx

<strong>“I have no way of making sure she gets justice or is not forgotten.”</strong>On March 28, 2020, Janie Marshall lost her footing and stumbled near another woman while both were being treated for non-COVID-19 ailments at a Brooklyn hospital. With the pandemic raging, an encounter that days earlier might have ended in a friendly apology or a cluck of sympathy quickly turned ugly. Authorities say the other woman, Cassandra Lundy, shoved Marshall, 86, for having “got into [Lundy’s] space” and violating new social-distancing orders aimed at containing the virus. Marshall—who had dementia and was in the hospital for stomach issues—fell to the ground, hit her head and later died.

The city’s medical examiner ruled the death a homicide, and Lundy, now 33, was charged with manslaughter and assault. It was the city’s first homicide associated with COVID-19, and, nearly a year later, one more piece of evidence that the U.S. system of justice can be counted a casualty of the virus. Among its many impacts—none of them good—closed courthouses and canceled jury trials mean neither victims nor defendants, much less their anxious families, can be assured of attending trials in person. And there’s no telling when that will change.
“Every time I think about my aunt, I well up in tears,” says Marshall’s niece, Eleanor Leonard, 74. “I want this over. And I won’t have peace, and I don’t think my aunt has peace in her grave, until this woman is convicted.”
Mark Clennon for TIMEFramed photographs of Janie Marshall, at the home of her niece Eleanor Leonard in Brooklyn, New York on Feb. 15, 2021.

Since COVID-19 was declared a national emergency in March 2020, every state and Washington, D.C., has canceled or scaled back in-person criminal court proceedings to stem the spread of the virus. The snarled justice system has left hundreds of thousands of families waiting for trials and other resolutions, while creating a cascade of civil rights issues for the accused. More defendants, especially those with health problems, are striking plea deals to avoid sitting in jail for an undetermined amount of time, defense attorneys say. And virtual courts are exposing the disadvantages of the poor, who are less likely to afford Internet access for court dates, as a staggering number of new criminal cases stack up.

<strong>“The pandemic is exerting a real influence on people’s basic rights and dignity and their ability to go free.”</strong>New York City alone is bogged down with about 49,000 pending criminal court cases, while Maine has 22,000 pending criminal cases, officials say. Florida’s court system says it needs $12.5 million to crawl out from beneath a mountain of more than 1.1 million stalled cases. California’s courts were recently given $25 million by the state’s Judicial Council to do the same.

In San Antonio, a moratorium on in-person criminal jury trials has extended the pileup of indicted pending felony cases to roughly 9,500—a nearly 67% increase since March 2020, according to Ron Rangel, a criminal district court judge in Bexar County, Texas. There, the family of slain firefighter Scott Deem is growing weary in anticipation of a court date that never seems to come. Deem, 31, died battling an arson fire in a gym on May 18, 2017, authorities say. While a grand jury indicted the gym’s owner, Emond Johnson, on felony murder and arson charges later that year, he has still not faced a jury. “It’s never-ending,” says Deem’s mother Susan Deem.

Deem’s family was hopeful Johnson would be tried in 2020 after a judge in November 2019 rejected a defense motion to move the trial out of the county. “But then the pandemic hit,” Deem’s mother says. With the trial still looming, Susan Deem, 52, says it’s a constant reminder of what was lost when her son died—a loving father, whose third child was born three months after his death, and a courageous public servant. “Every time there is some kind of hearing, it just brings back everything all over again,” she says. “That’s the hard part. I wish it would just get over and done with.”

If the current state of the public-health crisis is any indicator, that may not happen for a long time. In January, COVID-19 killed more people in the U.S. than in any other month so far, and the nation’s death toll stands at more than 498,000, according to data from Johns Hopkins University. In Bexar County, where Johnson’s trial would be held, jury trials have been under an unyielding freeze that will last at least until the end of March 2021. Rangel, who’s tasked with determining whether to lift the moratorium then, says he “currently cannot foresee” doing so.

‘We’re sort of in this holding period.’

The first few courts in the U.S. to stop jury selection and postpone new criminal and civil trials did so around the time of Marshall’s death in March, when health officials began urging millions of Americans to stay at home and keep 6 ft. away from others when venturing out. Even the U.S. Supreme Court postponed oral arguments for the first time in more than 100 years. By fall 2020, some criminal jury trials had resumed with restrictions, including in areas of New York State, where each county was allowed to hold one criminal trial at a time in courtrooms outfitted with plexiglass barriers and jury seats spaced several feet apart. But the reopening was short-lived. A surge in COVID-19 cases around the holidays forced another round of court restrictions. At the end of November, about two dozen U.S. district courts nationwide resuspended jury trials and grand jury proceedings, marking a “significant pause” in efforts by federal courts to resume full operation, court officials said. Today, even in jurisdictions where in-person proceedings have resumed, limits on how many people can be in a courtroom at the same time for things like jury selection continue to slow the system.

“We’re in sort of this holding period,” says Paula Hannaford-Agor, director of the Center for Jury Studies at the National Center for State Courts (NSCS).

Read more: Why the Coronavirus Pandemic Has Caused a Widespread Existential Crisis

In a pre-pandemic world, state courts typically resolved 18 million felony and misdemeanor cases annually, according to an NSCS study in August 2020, and an estimated 8 million to 10 million U.S. citizens reported for jury duty each year. Hannaford-Agor does not see jury trials returning to any semblance of normality until at least 2022. About 45 to 60 people are needed for jury selection in most typical felony cases, she says. More than 600 prospective jurors in Manhattan were summoned for Harvey Weinstein’s high-profile rape trial, which ended in his conviction just before COVID-19 toppled the courts. “Most courts are not set up to be able to have that kind of group size while maintaining social distancing,” Hannaford-Agor says.

“Everybody keeps thinking, Well, we’re kind of getting to the end of this,” she adds. “I don’t think we are.”

With most trial proceedings at a standstill, a host of new problems plague the nation’s criminal-justice system. The longer it takes to bring a case to trial, the greater the chance key witnesses will die or forget details. That happened in Houston, where the arresting officer in a domestic-violence case died before the case went to trial. It has been delayed at least a dozen times in the past 17 months.

How remote courts hurt low-income defendants

There are also long-standing racial inequities underscored by remote courts. With record unemployment rates from the current crisis, low-income, minority defendants have struggled to get access to the Internet or to devices needed for virtual trials, hearings or conversations with attorneys, according to Tina Luongo, attorney-in-charge of the criminal-defense practice at the Legal Aid Society, who’s based in New York City.

“People lost their jobs, they’ve lost their homes,” Luongo says. “The last thing they’re thinking about is, Can I get on Skype or Microsoft Teams?”

Even more alarming to public defenders is how multiple states have suspended laws that set deadlines for prosecutors aimed at protecting defendants’ rights to speedy trials. Multiple defense attorneys say that without that deadline pressure and with no clear end in sight to their cases, more clients are pleading guilty in exchange for time served or probation. “There’s not that light at the end of the tunnel that says, ‘If I can just have my hearing or trial, I’m going to make my case.’” Luongo says. “Imagine what that feels like.”

Plea deals were overwhelmingly common before the pandemic. Of the nearly 80,000 defendants facing federal criminal cases in 2018, about 90% pleaded guilty and 2% went to trial, according to a Pew Research Center analysis of data collected by the federal judiciary. At the state level, jury trials in 2017 accounted for fewer than 3% of criminal dispositions in 22 jurisdictions with available data, the NSCS says. Add the fear of languishing in crowded jails—where prisoners are twice as likely as the general population to die from COVID-19, a recent report found—and the offer of a plea deal looks sweeter even though a criminal conviction can stigmatize someone for life and affect their affect ability to obtain housing, jobs and education. Still, with more than 2,400 COVID-19 deaths behind bars, according to the Marshall Project, immediate concerns about becoming infected may outweigh future repercussions.

Read more: COVID-19 Has Devastated the U.S. Prison and Jail Population

“The impacts on the rest of your life only matter if you’re alive,” says Skailer Qvistgaard, a Massachusetts trial attorney. “It doesn’t matter if you can’t find housing if you died in jail.”

Qvistgaard says one of his immunocompromised clients was ready to challenge his case in court after insisting he had been falsely accused of assault and battery. But after nearly two months sharing a jail cell in a facility with COVID-19 cases, the 39-year-old changed his mind and pleaded guilty in October in exchange for time served. “His goal was to stay alive,” Qvistgaard says. “There was no other way to get him out.”

The Legal Aid Society says a similar situation in New York prompted Michael Hilton, a 64-year-old client, to plead guilty to nonviolent parole violations, including not staying at a court-appointed shelter and missing an appointment with his parole officer. The nonprofit says Hilton, who has a weakened immune system because of HIV, feared exposure to the coronavirus at the shelter. He was unable to let his parole officer know he would miss their meeting because the parole system was in an “exceptional state of disarray during the pandemic,” according to Laura Eraso, a Legal Aid staff attorney. Rather than fight the case and risk more time in jail, Hilton took a plea agreement in October and was released under supervision from Rikers Island.

“The pandemic is exerting a real influence on people’s basic rights and dignity and their ability to go free,” says Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve, a criminal-justice researcher and Brown University sociology professor. “These aren’t really choices anymore.”

<strong>“I won’t have peace, and I don’t think my aunt has peace in her grave, until this woman is convicted.”</strong> 

Mark Clennon for TIMEEleanor Leonard holds a photograph of her aunt, Janie Marshall, at home in Brooklyn, New York on Feb. 15, 2021.

Cassandra Lundy’s attorney requested that she be freed on bail four times after she was arrested and charged in Janie Marshall’s death in April 2020, prosecutors said, but the court rejected each request to reduce her $200,000 bail. After nearly three months, an appeals court lowered it to $30,000, and Lundy was released on July 15, 2020. At a pretrial conference on Feb. 10, Lundy’s case was adjourned until May. Her attorney and a spokesperson for the Brooklyn Defender Services, which is representing her, did not respond to multiple requests for comment. A phone number listed for Lundy was disconnected, and nobody responded to an email sent to an address listed for her.

Marshall’s great-niece, Antoinette Leonard-Jean Charles, believes the pandemic must have played a role in the court’s decision to free her on bail. “I just thought of the irony of it,” Leonard-Jean Charles says. “She hit my aunt, trying to prevent COVID, and there she was in Rikers surrounded by it.”

When, or if, Lundy stands trial, Marshall’s niece, Eleanor Leonard, hopes to be in the courtroom. “I would just like to face her to see why she would do that to an old lady,” Leonard says. “I just want to be in the courtroom to see if she has anything to say.”

Read more: Tenants Behind on Rent, Landlords Struggling, Eviction Moratoriums Ending. Inside the Next Housing Crisis

Then, if given the chance, Leonard would want Lundy to hear her. She would explain how in one moment, the family was robbed of a “caring, loving person” who was a role model to her nieces and nephews, and a trailblazer. Marshall was an accountant at the Social Security Administration and the first African American to lead the department in which she worked, her family says. Marshall often regaled relatives with stories about her travels to Africa, and she made family trees and history books so they wouldn’t forget where they came from. “She was a sophisticated, pro-Black woman, who made you proud to be African American,” says Leonard-Jean Charles.

Marshall never married or had children and was private about her personal life, her family says. They thought she was an “old spinster” until they sorted through the possessions in her Brooklyn apartment after she died. In closets full of designer clothing, they found an engagement ring, a wedding dress and two sets of fine china. Leonard-Jean Charles, 41, later learned Marshall’s fiancé had died weeks before they were to marry. “She never told us about her pain, and she obviously carried a lot of pain,” she says.

Leonard-Jean Charles shares stories about Marshall at any opportunity and has been the family’s point person in the court case. But she feels helpless, with nothing to do but wait.

“When the courts are closed, you don’t know when you’re going to be able to do anything,” she says. “I have no way of making sure she gets justice or that she’s not forgotten.”

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

New top story from Time: President Trump’s Brother, Robert Trump, Dies at 71

https://ift.tt/3g1Evdc (NEW YORK) — President Donald Trump’s younger brother, Robert Trump, a businessman known for an even keel that seemed almost incompatible with the family name, died Saturday night after being hospitalized in New York, the president said in a statement. He was 71. The president visited his brother at a New York City hospital on Friday after White House officials said he had become seriously ill. Officials did not immediately release a cause of death. “It is with heavy heart I share that my wonderful brother, Robert, peacefully passed away tonight,” Donald Trump said in a statement. “He was not just my brother, he was my best friend. He will be greatly missed, but we will meet again. His memory will live on in my heart forever. Robert, I love you. Rest in peace.” The youngest of the Trump siblings had remained close to the 74-year-old president and, as recently as June, filed a lawsuit on behalf of the Trump family that unsuccessfully sought to stop ...

L Taraval Improvement Project “Segment B” Geared Up for Early 2022

L Taraval Improvement Project “Segment B” Geared Up for Early 2022 By Stephen Chun Over the summer, we shared the good news that the  first segment  of the  L Taraval Improvement Project  was  completed on schedule and within budget.  A notice to proceed for the next phase of work, Segment B was issued last week to NTK Construction. Project staff is now gearing up for work slated to begin in January 2022.   What is the L Taraval Improvement Project?  The L Taraval Improvement Project is a multi-agency collaboration partnered with the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission and the Department of Public Works to improve and upgrade the aging infrastructure. The project will make pedestrian crossing safer, increase accessibility, improve transit reliability, rehabilitate water and sewer infrastructure, enhance landscaping and replace road pavement along the L Taraval line....

FOX NEWS: Miniskirt named 'most iconic fashion statement of all time' in British survey

Miniskirt named 'most iconic fashion statement of all time' in British survey It’s official: Nobody remembers your sweet Members Only jacket from 1983. via FOX NEWS https://ift.tt/2yTg1Dn

New Express Service Comes to the 1 California

New Express Service Comes to the 1 California By Melissa Culross Newly painted Muni flag stop indicating the pilot 1X California Express Beginning February 21, 2023, a pilot program will offer express bus service on the new 1X California Express between the Richmond neighborhood and the Financial District. The SFMTA plays a significant role in San Francisco’s economic recovery, and this pilot that serves downtown is part of that.  We have been working on improving travel time and reliability over the last several years. Travel times are now 11% quicker on the 1 California thanks to new transit lanes on California, Clay and Sacramento streets. But our work is not done on the corridor! The new 1X California express will provide another option for riders to zoom from the inner Richmond into and out of downtown even faster. We also expect this service to ease crowding on the 1 California as more people head back to the office.  Three morning 1X California Express buses will ...

India vs Australia 4th Test Day 1: Follow Live Updates from Brisbane https://ift.tt/2LULefq

India vs Australia 4th Test Day 1 Live: Follow Live Updates from Brisbane IND vs AUS Live:  Hello and welcome to the live coverage of India vs Australia 4th Test Day 1 from Brisbane on indiatvnews.com. A bruised and battered Indian team will line up against hosts Australia at an intimidating venue -- The Gabba -- where the Kangaroos haven't lost since 1988. India have never won a Test at The Gabba, plunging the injury-ravaged touring side into further misery. More than turning the tables in Brisbane, the Ajinkya Rahane-led side will be aiming for a draw, especially when the touring party's dressing room resembles a hospital ward. After enduring a horror batting collapse in the Test series opener in Adelaide, the Indian team has put up impressive performances in Melbourne and Sydney, especially when they were dealing with an injury-plagued unit. After a gutsy and awe-inspiring show in Sydney, the fourth Test will be nothing but a 'flight for glory' for the Indian side. ...

Breaking news LIVE: Top Headlines This Hour https://ift.tt/2Flexoe

The total number of global coronavirus cases has surpassed 21.6 million, including more than 768,000 fatalities. More than 14,321,000 patients are reported to have recovered. Follow this breaking news blog for live updates on coronavirus pandemic as it continues to pose a challenge for health workers and scientists who are in a race against time to produce a vaccine/medicine. On Tuesday, Russia became the first country to register the world's first coronavirus vaccine. President Vladimir Putin himself endorsed the vaccine and said that the vaccine was safe to use and that one of his daughters had already been vaccinated.

New top story from Time: Facebook Wanted to Be a Force for Good in Myanmar. Now Its Rejecting a Request to Help With a Genocide Investigation

https://ift.tt/2DT0fLt Just when it seemed like Facebook’s controversies might have peaked, the company now appears to be obstructing a genocide investigation , and it’s using U.S. law to do it. The West African nation The Gambia is seeking to hold Myanmar accountable for charges of genocide against the Rohingya people , an ethnic and religious minority. In 2016 and 2017, Myanmar soldiers and their civilian proxies massacred Rohingya men, women and children, raped women and girls and razed villages, forcing more than 800,000 to flee into neighboring Bangladesh. Facebook’s role in these atrocities isn’t news. In 2018, Facebook acknowledged it was used to “foment division and incite offline violence” in Myanmar, where the social media platform is so ubiquitous it’s often synonymous with the internet. An independent report commissioned by the company documented the same, as did independent fact-finders appointed by the U.N. In response, Facebook took down the account ...

Safer Intersections Project a Traffic Calming Success

Safer Intersections Project a Traffic Calming Success By Uyen Ngo This week the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) released “ A Turn Toward Safety: The Safer Intersections Project ,” a report detailing the impact of the Left Turn Traffic Calming Project and the “Safety—It’s Your Turn” education campaign. The Safer Intersections Project now has tested traffic interventions that can reduce unsafe left turns. Overall, SFMTA found a 17% reduction in average speed (1.7mph slower) and a 71% reduction in the likelihood of a car turning left at higher speeds over 15mph at seven high-crash test intersections. In 2019, 40% of traffic deaths in San Francisco were caused when drivers made left turns and didn’t see the person in the crosswalk, until it was too late. To combat this trend, also seen in other cities, and encourage safer left turns and adoption of safer left turn behaviors, San Francisco’s multilayered project combined engineering treatments in seven high-crash ...

More Muni Service Coming in August

More Muni Service Coming in August By Julie Kirschbaum The SFMTA is updating and expanding our next big service change targeted for August 14. These adjustments take into account stakeholder feedback and changes in COVID-19 regulations like physical distancing and our ability to switch operators in the field rather than having to return vehicles to their yards first for cleaning. Enhancements to our previously announced plan include expanding evening service and restoring Muni Owl All-nighter service, adding back four more routes and restoring or adjusting segments on several others. Expanded Evening Service As San Francisco reopens, people are traveling later for work, shopping and dining. To help workers and shoppers get around town we plan to expand service hours on 16 key routes. Instead of 5 a.m. to 10 p.m., these routes will operate from 5 a.m. to midnight. Muni’s full late-night Owl network is scheduled to be restored in August, providing service from midnight to 5 a.m....

New top story from Time: Deaths and Blackouts Have Hit the U.S. Northwest Due to the Unprecedented Heat Wave

https://ift.tt/2UgzckI SPOKANE, Wash. — The unprecedented Northwest U.S. heat wave that slammed Seattle and Portland, Oregon, moved inland Tuesday — prompting a electrical utility in Spokane, Washington, to resume rolling blackouts amid heavy power demand. Officials said a dozen deaths in Washington and Oregon may be tied to the intense heat that began late last week. The dangerous weather that gave Seattle and Portland consecutive days of record high temperatures exceeding 100 degrees Fahrenheit (37.7 degrees Celcius) was expected to ease in those cities. But inland Spokane saw temperatures spike. The National Weather Service said the mercury reached 109 F (42.2 C) in Spokane— the highest temperature ever recorded there. [time-brightcove not-tgx=”true”] About 9,300 Avista Utilities customers in Spokane lost power on Monday and the company said more planned blackouts began on Tuesday afternoon in the city of about 220,000 people. “We try to limit outages to one hour per...