Skip to main content

New top story from Time: ‘Medical Populism’ Has Defined the Philippines’ Response to COVID-19. That’s Why the Country Is Still Suffering

https://ift.tt/2SwLHIx

Nurse Delta Santiago (not her real name) has reached the top of her field. She works at one of the Philippines’ top hospitals, frequented by billionaires and celebrities. But the 32-year-old can’t wait to leave. Santiago makes just $520 a month working 12-hour days and she’s desperate to land a job overseas.

Because of the pandemic, the authorities have imposed restrictions on public transport, and Santiago’s 15-mile (24-kilometer) commute to work in the center of the capital Manila is a time-consuming ordeal. She wants to rent a room closer to her workplace, to cut down on the exhausting traveling, and to avoid the risk of bringing COVID-19 home to her family, but she can’t afford to. So, for the past eight months, she has been sleeping in a utility room at the hospital, just steps away from the plush, private medical suites where high-paying patients recline in relative comfort.
[time-brightcove not-tgx=”true”]

There, on a thin mattress spread between rolls of black garbage bags and boxes of toilet disinfectant, an exhausted Santiago crams for the professional exams that could be her ticket to the United States. She also has video calls with her eight-year-old son, whom she rarely sees in person. And she seethes with fury at the needlessness of the suffering that COVID-19 has brought to the Philippines.

“I felt rage during the second surge,” Miranda says, convinced that it could have been prevented.

Dr. Alejandro Umali, a physician working at a private hospital, rides his bike to work in Pasig, Metro Manila, on April 26. Many Filipinos, including health care workers, are hopping on bicycles as an alternative means of transportation as public transit remains restricted during the world's longest COVID-19 lockdown.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesDr. Alejandro Umali, a physician working at a private hospital, rides his bike to work in Pasig, Metro Manila, on April 26. Many Filipinos, including health care workers, are hopping on bicycles as an alternative means of transportation as public transit remains restricted during the world’s longest COVID-19 lockdown.
Dr. Alejandro Umali wears personal protective equipment inside the COVID-19 ward of The Medical City, a private hospital, in Pasig, Metro Manila, on April 26.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesDr. Alejandro Umali wears personal protective equipment inside the COVID-19 ward on April 26.
A police officer inspects motorists at a checkpoint in Marikina, Metro Manila, on March 29, as a strict quarantine is reimposed in Manila and surrounding provinces to curb the spread of COVID-19.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesA police officer inspects motorists at a checkpoint in Marikina, Metro Manila, on March 29, as a strict quarantine is reimposed in Manila and surrounding provinces to curb the spread of COVID-19.

The Southeast Asian country of 109 million people was already struggling to contain one of the region’s worst outbreaks of when numbers began to climb sharply upwards in March this year. Typical daily caseloads have ranged from 3,000 to 7,000 in the past three months, but have been as high as 10,000 or 11,000, and hit an official peak of 15,310 on Apr. 2—a figure that is almost certainly an undercount. Less than 5.5% of the population has been vaccinated, according to WHO figures.

What happens in the Philippines matters for the world’s efforts to contain COVID-19. Like Narendra Modi’s India or Jair Bolsonaro’s Brazil, the country is ruled by a “medical populist”—a term devised by Philippine physician and medical anthropologist Gideon Lasco, and fellow researcher Nicole Curato, to convey how public health crises are vulnerable to authoritarian figures who belittle threats, pooh-pooh scientific data and proffer improvised solutions. Under President Rodrigo Duterte, the country’s COVID-19 containment strategy remains a wild card, affecting not only the Philippines itself but the millions of workers it exports around the world, and the countries relying on Filipinos to fill vital jobs as construction workers, domestic workers, seafarers and medical personnel.

That’s why many like Santiago are in despair. “We’re back to zero again,” she says.

Katrina Pelotin, a field nurse from the City Epidemiology and Surveillance Unit, conducts a swab test on a family member of a COVID-19 patient isolating at home as part of contact tracing efforts in Quezon City, Metro Manila, on April 15.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesKatrina Pelotin, a field nurse from the City Epidemiology and Surveillance Unit, conducts a swab test on a family member of a COVID-19 patient isolating at home as part of contact tracing efforts in Quezon City, Metro Manila, on April 15.

A devastating second COVID-19 wave

The second Philippine wave wasn’t supposed to happen because the country has been undergoing one of the world’s longest and harshest lockdowns—a draconian measure meant to keep it safe in the absence of mass testing or a widespread vaccination program. Quarantine orders of differing degrees have been rolled out across the archipelago since March 2020, enforced by armed security personnel in a manner described in April by United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet as “highly militarized.” Duterte himself has appeared on television telling the police and military to kill any anti-lockdown protesters who resist arrest. His bloody war on drugs had already eroded civil liberties; now, rights groups say, political freedoms have deteriorated further.

And yet the hardship of life under lockdown, which sent the country into its worst economic contraction since World War II, seems to have had little payoff. Since the onset of the second wave—triggered, some reports suggest, by new, more transmissible strains of the virus that causes COVID-19 spreading in the community after some social-distancing measures were lifted—hospitals have again been pushed to breaking point. The nation’s total COVID deaths have nearly doubled during the four months of the second wave, spiking from just over 12,300 on Mar. 1 to nearly 24,400 on June 27.

“People were dying at parking lots, even at home, because they could not find hospitals that would admit them. It was horrible,” is how Dr. Glenn Butuyan describes the start of the second wave. Media reports described medical supplies running low and ambulances becoming makeshift morgues, lining up outside crematoriums. Tragically, the country continues to dispatch medical workers around the globe, even as its own hospitals stand in dire need of health care personnel.

Filipinos who are economically suffering as a result of the pandemic wait in line for free goods at the Maginhawa community pantry in Quezon City, Metro Manila, on April 19. The pantry is stocked with donated basic necessities such as food, toiletries and medicines.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesFilipinos who are economically suffering as a result of the pandemic wait in line for free goods at the Maginhawa community pantry in Quezon City on April 19. The pantry is stocked with donated basic necessities such as food, toiletries and medicines.
Funeral workers carry the corpse of a COVID-19 victim at a public crematorium in Pasay, Metro Manila, on April 21.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesFuneral workers carry the corpse of a COVID-19 victim at a public crematorium in Pasay, Metro Manila, on April 21.
Cemetery workers grind the ashes of a COVID-19 victim at a public crematorium in Pasay, Metro Manila, on April 21.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesCemetery workers grind the ashes of a COVID-19 victim at a public crematorium in Pasay on April 21.

Today, the situation has stabilized somewhat. There were just over 6,096 new cases, by official count, reported on June 27—a small improvement on the situation a month earlier, when at least 7,000 cases were being logged every day.

But “Nurses are exhausted,” says Butuyan, who heads a hospital in Isabela province, about 250 miles (400 kilometers) north of Manila, and says he has been battling COVID-19 “without any financial support” from the government. (Health Secretary Francisco Duque III declined to be interviewed for this story, as did the health ministry’s spokesperson, undersecretary Maria Rosario Vergeire. Harry Roque, the presidential spokesperson, also declined to comment.)

“We don’t have enough rooms,” Butuyan tells TIME. “Medicines are difficult to procure. We are so tired.”

The mild, 54-year-old physician is well known in the Philippines for releasing a video message in early April that went viral. His call on the government to step up its efforts to contain the virus resonated with his long-suffering compatriots.

“I was frustrated. There were so many cases, the hospitals were overwhelmed, and we were not getting much help from agencies that should be helping front liners,” Butuyan says about his decision to release the video.

But he also used the message “to beg [people to shelter at home] because we could no longer handle people dying”—and that was harder to stomach for many Filipinos. Mark Vincent Navera is an aspiring accountant in Lipa City, about 50 miles (85 kilometers) south of the capital. He says repeated lockdowns have led to the cancellation of three professional examinations, costing him jobs that would have brought financial relief to his family, many of whom caught COVID-19. “At the rate we’re going, we’re still far from gaining our freedom,” he says.

An electronic billboard displays a video of Duterte as Catholic devotees pray outside a closed church in Manila on April 2, defying government orders to avoid religious gatherings and stay home during Holy Week to curb the spread of the coronavirus.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesAn electronic billboard displays a video of Duterte as Catholic devotees pray outside a closed church in Manila on April 2, defying government orders to avoid religious gatherings and stay home during Holy Week to curb the spread of the coronavirus.

Duterte’s medical populism

Poor leadership and lack of a coherent pandemic strategy have added to the country’s woes. President Duterte disappeared from public view as cases began to climb sharply in March. To allay questions about his health, photos of the president playing golf were released in early April, but the images conveyed an impression of remoteness from the suffering of ordinary Filipinos and were widely mocked.

When he finally resumed the weekly televised addresses to the nation that have been such a feature of the pandemic in the Philippines, Duterte was only able to offer the same solutions he has always favored: place affected areas under a total lockdown, put more police on the streets, impose stricter curfews, and arrest quarantine violators.

“There is no imagination,” the medical anthropologist Lasco tells TIME. It is hallmark medical populism, which he and his colleague define as a political style during “public health crises that pits ‘the people’ against ‘the establishment.’”

According to Lasco and Curato: “While some health emergencies lead to technocratic responses that soothe the anxieties of a panicked public, medical populism thrives by politicizing, simplifying, and spectacularizing complex public health issues.”

Figures like Duterte, Bolsonaro, Modi, and former U.S. president Donald Trump have downplayed the impact of the virus, spread false claims, and touted their own bizarre solutions to the problem, preventing scientists and doctors from leading the fight. As the first wave of the pandemic raged in India, Modi called for festivals of light and asked the air force to dispatch helicopters to shower hospitals with flower petals. Trump said he was taking anti-malarial drug hydroxychloroquine as a prophylactic against COVID-19, despite little evidence on its efficacy against the disease and evidence that misuse of the drug could cause harm. Brazil’s Bolsonaro infamously called COVID-19 “a little flu” and has continuously belittled mask wearing, even though he himself was diagnosed with COVID.

Instead of investing in testing or ensuring a timely rollout of vaccines, Duterte’s approach has been to put the Philippines on a war footing, which Lasco describes as part of the medical populist’s “pattern of spectacle.” The president appears on TV to give COVID-19 updates while flanked by top military brass and has appointed several military figures to senior positions in his campaign against the virus. With the country distracted by the pandemic, the administration has also cracked down on political opponents. On Mar. 7, at the start of the second wave, nine activists were shot dead in the so called “Bloody Sunday” raids around Manila.

Professor Ranjit Rye is a member of a research group from University of the Philippines that has been monitoring the pandemic. He says a big part of the problem is that “scientists are not prime movers” in the inter-agency task force created to handle the nation’s pandemic response. “Scientists and doctors are not treated as equals,” he says. “They are just one of the stakeholders there”—competing, the professor claims, with business interests who want the economy reopened.

A crate containing Sinovac Biotech COVID-19 vaccines is loaded into a truck upon arrival at Ninoy Aquino International Airport in Manila on Feb. 28. Duterte witnessed the arrival of 600,000 doses donated by the Chinese government.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesA crate containing Sinovac Biotech COVID-19 vaccines is loaded into a truck upon arrival at Ninoy Aquino International Airport in Manila on Feb. 28. Duterte witnessed the arrival of 600,000 doses donated by the Chinese government.
Health Secretary Francisco Duque III administers a shot of Sinovac Biotech's CoronaVac vaccine on a health care worker during the first day of COVID-19 vaccinations at the Lung Center of the Philippines Hospital in Quezon City on March 1.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesHealth Secretary Francisco Duque III administers a shot of Sinovac Biotech’s CoronaVac vaccine on a health care worker during the first day of COVID-19 vaccinations at the Lung Center of the Philippines Hospital in Quezon City on March 1.
A makeshift vaccination center in San Juan, Metro Manila, on June 1.
Ezra Acayan—Getty ImagesA makeshift vaccination center in San Juan, Metro Manila, on June 1.

If nothing is done to prop up the country’s ailing health system, Rye and his colleagues believe the Philippines could go the way of India—caught unprepared by a giant surge and hamstrung by a woeful shortage of resources, especially health care workers. One nurse, Czar Dancel, tells TIME that 8 out of his 10 colleagues are preparing to leave the country, mostly because of a lack of money. He reveals that his monthly hazard pay amounts to just 300 Philippine pesos—a little over $6—and even then he has yet to receive a single centavo of it.

For the time being, the country’s pandemic response lurches onward under its erratic, authoritarian leader. Duterte has recently started espousing vaccinations as the country’s way out of the crisis, but its inoculation program didn’t begin until March, using donated CoronaVac jabs from China. Achieving herd immunity any time soon looks highly unlikely. Vaccine hesitancy is deep-rooted. Many Filipinos are refusing to be jabbed with Chinese-made shots and a recent poll found that fear of vaccination’s side effects was a major concern.

For now, that leaves further lockdowns and social-distancing as the chief means of preventing an even more severe outbreak among an already exhausted population.

“None of us thought lockdowns would be this long,” says Manila bookseller Honey de Peralta, who stays at home with two children and an elderly parent. “None of us expected we would go back to square one.”

More intimidation could also be on the cards. On June 21, Duterte threatened to jail anyone refusing to be vaccinated. “You choose, vaccine or I will have you jailed,” he warned on television.

“We have the same set of responses, and there’s no willingness to acknowledge the mistakes of the past,” says Lasco. “It’s hard to feel optimistic.”

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Bihar: Stages collapse during Congress rallies in Darbhanga, West Champaran https://ift.tt/37QFnks

The stage on which Congress candidate from Jale assembly seat, Mashkoor Ahmad Usman was addressing a rally broke and collapsed in Bihar's Darbhanga on Thursday. In a similar incident, another stage collapsed and took down party leaders Imran Pratapgarhi and Akhilesh Singh along with several party workers who were on the dias, during a Congress rally at Bagahi Deoraj in Champaran.

New Dashboards Give a Window into Muni Service Changes

New Dashboards Give a Window into Muni Service Changes By Kate McCarthy An inspector manages Muni service. New dashboards that help inform changes to Muni service are now live at SFMTA.com/MuniData Many factors inform our decisions about Muni service adjustments. These include making sure changes to service support the SFMTA’s values, which are economic vitality, environmental stewardship, trust and equity. We also evaluate travel patterns. You can now explore these patterns using the new Muni data dashboards  (SFMTA.com/MuniData). When looking at possible Muni service changes, the first thing we do is turn to the Muni Service Equity Strategy for guidance. Using the Muni Service Equity Strategy, we prioritize providing Muni service along routes that more often serve people of color, members of low-income households, and/or those who are dependent upon transit service, including people with disabilities and seniors. We also use ridership data to analyze where riders are boa...

India reports first 6 cases of new coronavirus strain after UK returnees test positive https://ift.tt/3pA0T2j

India on Tuesday reported the first six cases of the new coronavirus strain after six people who had returned from the United Kingdom were tested positive for the new UK variant genome. According to the details, the new coronavirus strain cases were reported from Hyderabad, Pune and Bangalore. Samples of 3 UK returnees were tested and found positive for the new UK strain in NIMHANS, Bengaluru. The other two cases were tested at the Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology, Hyderabad; while the last case was tested at the National Institute of Virology, Pune.

FOX NEWS: Ohio amusement park shut down after multiple fights break out Kings Island in Mason, around 20 miles north of Cincinnati, closed down 30 minutes early Saturday night after several fights among teenagers occurred, reports suggest.

Ohio amusement park shut down after multiple fights break out Kings Island in Mason, around 20 miles north of Cincinnati, closed down 30 minutes early Saturday night after several fights among teenagers occurred, reports suggest. via FOX NEWS https://ift.tt/3wsn8uI

PM Modi lauds IFS officers for their work towards serving nation, furthering national interests https://ift.tt/36HoEzw

Greeting Indian Foreign Service officers on IFS day, Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Friday said that their work towards serving the nation and furthering national interests globally are commendable. Their efforts during the Vande Bharat Mission, which was launched to bring Indians home from abroad during the COVID-19 pandemic as international travel came to a halt, and other related help to our citizens and other nations is noteworthy, Modi added.

FOX NEWS: Bride's father asks stepdad to help walk her down the aisle in sweet viral moment A selfless gesture by the father of a bride was shared on social media in a viral moment of him surprising the girl’s stepfather by asking him to help walk her to the altar.

Bride's father asks stepdad to help walk her down the aisle in sweet viral moment A selfless gesture by the father of a bride was shared on social media in a viral moment of him surprising the girl’s stepfather by asking him to help walk her to the altar. via FOX NEWS https://ift.tt/ZkQ1Rpt

Better Connections from Bayview and Hunters Point to Downtown

Better Connections from Bayview and Hunters Point to Downtown By Enrique Aguilar To better connect southeast San Franciscans with downtown, the SFMTA debuted the 15 Bayview Hunters-Point Express in late January, coinciding with the return of T Third train service. Within weeks, average daily boardings reached 1,000 customers on this new service. The 15 Bayview Hunters Point Express  We added this route based on community feedback from the Southeast Muni Expansion Project in 2018, which prioritized a more direct trip to downtown from the Bayview. With the sudden rise of the COVID-19 pandemic and its disproportionate impacts on communities in the Bayview and Hunters Point, fast-tracking the project became critical to our transit planning. Adding service capacity and a direct connection between these neighborhoods and downtown is a crucial step in supporting the City’s economic recovery and increasing job access for essential workers using transit. Using data from the SFMTA Equ...

Plan Your Next Golden Gate Park Trip with Muni

Plan Your Next Golden Gate Park Trip with Muni By Eillie Anzilotti   A map of San Francisco showing Muni lines that offer direct service to Golden Gate Park, including: The 18 46th Avenue, the 29 Sunset, the 5 Fulton and 5R Fulton Rapid, the N Judah, the 44 O’Shaughnessy, the 33 Ashbury/18th Street, the 7 Haight/Noriega, the 43 Masonic and the 28 19th Avenue. Around each bus route shown on the map, a red zone shows the range within 1,000 feet of a stop, orange shows within 2,000 feet of a stop, and yellow shows within 3,000 feet. Here’s a fun fact: 70% of San Franciscans are within a 15-minute walk of a transfer-free Muni ride to the largest public space in our city: Golden Gate Park.   Especially as COVID-19 has heightened the importance of outdoor recreation and park access, SFMTA has made efforts to update Muni service to get people to Golden Gate Park. As of now, ...

New top story from Time: ‘I Should Be Presumed Innocent.’ Hong Kong Media Tycoon Jimmy Lai Criticizes His Arrest

https://ift.tt/342b8VJ Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai said he was arrested on “trumped up” charges, pushing back against landmark national security legislation that has raised questions about press freedoms and the future of the democracy movement. “They’re trumped up. I can’t go further on the details,” Lai said in an interview with Bloomberg Television on Friday morning. “Before any evidence, they just claimed and presumed that I’m guilty. This isn’t the way the law is. I should be presumed innocent. We have never supported the independence of Hong Kong.” He said Hong Kong’s future as Asia’s main financial hub was uncertain if there was no respect for the rule of law under the new security measures. “The future of Hong Kong is the future of any other Chinese city,” he added. “Without the rule of law, the international financial center will be finished.” He added that the law sent a “very negative” message to the business community in Hong Kong and overseas. Lai has ...

अगर मैंने आत्महत्या की तो लोगों को पता होना चाहिए किसकी वजह से की - फूटकर रोते दिखे विकास गुप्ता

सुशांत सिंह राजपूत की आत्महत्या हर किसी को एक गहरा सदमा दे गई है और अब सुशांत के करीबी दोस्त विकास गुप्ता ने एक वीडियो में अपनी आपबीती सुनाई है। विकास इस वीडियो में बेहद टूटे हुए नज़र आ रहे हैं from टेलीविजन की खबरें | Television News in Hindi | TV Serials Update in Hindi – FilmiBeat Hindi http:/hindi.filmibeat.com/television/vikas-gupta-reveals-people-want-him-to-commit-suicide-cries-his-heart-out-for-sushant-singh-rajput-090284.html?utm_source=/rss/filmibeat-hindi-television-fb.xml&utm_medium=23.213.205.12&utm_campaign=client-rss